One place, more than one flow
Two live flows carry the same substance, the same context and the same unit -- three of the fields deduplication signs on. They were not collapsed, because it compares every other field of the record as well and found one they disagree on. That field, shown as what holds them apart, is the whole of what keeps them two. Where it is the general comment -- a free-text note -- they are one edit to a source list away from being merged, and the flow holding fewer characterisation factors would lose them. That is #255, where a balanced pair of water withdrawal and return factors became a one-sided charge. Everything else the flows disagree on is listed under each of them: the names, most often, which deduplication does not read at all and a curator does. So: two flows, or one? Answering one means a ruling in `elementary-flow-collision-decisions.json`, which names the flow that survives and carries the other's factors and source references onto it. Answering two means leaving them alone, which is what the pipeline already does. A row marked `review` is a different question and takes a different answer: there the merge minted the flows, answering a curated grouping by writing a flow onto a place another flow already held, where the same grouping attaches a source reference to the flow that is there when the substance is in the prepared correspondence table (#361). Those minted flows carry no characterisation factors, and a ruling in the decisions file does nothing to them -- deduplication and the rulings both run before the merge, so nothing has ever inspected these. What answers them is which of the two treatments the grouping should have had.
elementary-flow-collision
2 live flows share Methyl Trifluoromethyl Ether in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-48ed32f86342331a
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors | Alternative labels | General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 341eab87-065e-40a8-87f4-87d78776999b | Methyl trifluoromethyl ether | EF 3.1 | 0 | — | Name interchanged with one synonym. Reference elementary flow of the International Reference Life Cycle Data System (IL… |
| 9308d9b4-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | HFE-143a | EF 3.1 | 2 | HFE-143a | — |
2 live flows share Methyl Trifluoromethyl Ether in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-48ed32f86342331a
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Long-term
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors | Alternative labels | General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6ad38d57-385e-4cd7-8c2f-fad75b9a185f | Methyl trifluoromethyl ether | EF 3.1 | 0 | — | Name interchanged with one synonym. Reference elementary flow of the International Reference Life Cycle Data System (IL… |
| 9308d5e0-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | HFE-143a | EF 3.1 | 2 | HFE-143a | — |
2 live flows share Methyl Trifluoromethyl Ether in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-48ed32f86342331a
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors | Alternative labels | General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9308d8f6-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | HFE-143a | EF 3.1 | 2 | HFE-143a | — |
| bf80615e-1c05-4274-aac2-78f4c0fcd390 | Methyl trifluoromethyl ether | EF 3.1 | 0 | — | Name interchanged with one synonym. Reference elementary flow of the International Reference Life Cycle Data System (IL… |
2 live flows share Methyl Trifluoromethyl Ether in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-48ed32f86342331a
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Unknown
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors | Alternative labels | General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5a24f510-a2be-4ff7-b0f2-d90884572b90 | Methyl trifluoromethyl ether | EF 3.1 | 0 | — | Name interchanged with one synonym. Reference elementary flow of the International Reference Life Cycle Data System (IL… |
| 9308ce4c-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | HFE-143a | EF 3.1 | 2 | HFE-143a | — |
2 live flows share Water vapour in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-757b6ee59c695209
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Unknown
- Unit
- m3
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors |
Alternative labels
only what is not shared
|
General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0342f5e5-b53e-4cec-9e67-fb197f24fff0 would be kept | Water | EF 3.1 | 0 | — | — |
| 4b772bba-b5c1-4098-9c1d-3d9d8c74c7fa | Water (evapotranspiration) | EF 3.1 | 0 | Water, Water (evapotranspiration) | water vapour, but coming from growing renewables. Some "water people" like to distinguish between water vapour and evap… |
2 live flows share HFE-569sf2 in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-8e701ffd05fb4bc1
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors |
Alternative labels
only what is not shared
|
General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1b258cbc-798d-4d86-81c1-3cb852a54e8f would be kept | HFE-569sf2 | EF 3.1 | 2 | — | Name did not match ILCD nomenclature. Interchanged with one of the synonyms. Reference elementary flow of the Internati… |
| a19b9bce-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 | n-HFE-7200 | EF 3.1 | 2 | n-HFE-7200 | — |
2 live flows share HFE-569sf2 in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-8e701ffd05fb4bc1
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Long-term
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors |
Alternative labels
only what is not shared
|
General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a19b95ca-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | n-HFE-7200 | EF 3.1 | 2 | n-HFE-7200 | — |
| f9c7caa5-1b99-4ce5-846c-9ca86fc074c2 | HFE-569sf2 | EF 3.1 | 2 | — | Name did not match ILCD nomenclature. Interchanged with one of the synonyms. Reference elementary flow of the Internati… |
2 live flows share HFE-569sf2 in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-8e701ffd05fb4bc1
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors |
Alternative labels
only what is not shared
|
General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a19b98f4-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | n-HFE-7200 | EF 3.1 | 2 | n-HFE-7200 | — |
| ed1c4bbd-43e8-432d-8752-1a211ae0e573 | HFE-569sf2 | EF 3.1 | 2 | — | Name did not match ILCD nomenclature. Interchanged with one of the synonyms. Reference elementary flow of the Internati… |
2 live flows share HFE-569sf2 in one context and unit
- Substance
- fo-8e701ffd05fb4bc1
- Context
- Environmental → Air → Unknown
- Unit
- kg
- Held apart by
- General comment
| Flow | Shipped as | Source list | Factors |
Alternative labels
only what is not shared
|
General comment holds apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a19b92e6-e251-11e6-bf01-fe55135034f3 would be kept | n-HFE-7200 | EF 3.1 | 2 | n-HFE-7200 | — |
| b0681715-c852-4456-ab78-c88e68502c7a | HFE-569sf2 | EF 3.1 | 2 | — | Name did not match ILCD nomenclature. Interchanged with one of the synonyms. Reference elementary flow of the Internati… |